Table of Contents
When it comes to colored eyeliners sets, you need to know what best suits you, and what impact you want to have!
Depending on your eye color, you can choose to complement and highlight your eye color and shape or you may want to have a dramatic colorful effect.
Either way, you need to have the right colors, texture, and applicator to get the right effect.
And in today’s new reality when we all need to where masks – our eyes are our last “statement of beauty” where we can make a beautiful impact.
This is why I have chosen here to give you more of the glittering eyeliners and some of them double as eye shadow, with these you are sure to make the right impression!
Applied in a dramatic and artistic way, these colored eyeliners can make your eyes look very alluring.
No matter what color you choose, you need to know what would be the best-colored eyeliners that will hold throughout the day, not run or smudge, and not irritate your eyes.
So finding a hypoallergenic, smudge-free, good quality color eyeliners is important.
In this article, we are going to look at 8 of the best color eyeliners sets on the market, ones that answer to four important criteria:
- Hypoallergenic
- Smudge-free
- Best quality
- Amazon Ranking
Set #1 – G2PLUS 12 PCS Colorful Eyeliners Eyebrow Lip Liner Pencil Pen Makeup Cosmetic Set Kit Tool
This set is one of the best selling as it is so versatile, you can use it as eyeliner, brow liner, and lip liner.
This is a hypoallergenic eyeliners set that is simply one of the best!
Being in pen form they retract nicely back so you don’t break the tips. The color range is bright and strong, to get maximum impact.
These liners are simply great as they are highly water resistant when you let them dry properly, and are hypoallergenic, they are easy to hold and control.
You 
need to remember in order to produce various colors a varying amount of titanium dioxides, wax, and iron oxides are used and that makes the color more or less soft.
There is a 100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEED-RISK FREE! If you are completely unsatisfied with your purchase, they will be glad to replace it or issue you a full refund.
The reviews are mainly great, and that makes me more confident in recommending these to you.
Where to Buy
As with most of the eyeliners reviewed here, Amazon is the ‘Go-To’ site for the best-priced colored eyeliners. Priced at of $10.59 that is a great deal!
Stats
Out of 932 reviews, 44% have given this set a 5-star rating, which considering the fierce competition on the Amazon platform for colored eyeliners, is a feat in itself.
When looking at reviews and ranking factors, this set’s ranking is #19, 124 in Amazon’s Best Seller rank these are noteworthy stats, and #390 in Eyeliner ranking.
Set #2 – Matte Liquid Eyeliner 12 Colors Waterproof
This Matte Liquid Eyeliner set has 12 different colored eyeliners with bright pigments.
This is a liquid eyeliner set which is ideal for parties, cosmetic shows, live shows, prom night, and wedding makeup.
It has a long-lasting effect with minimum maintenance, as it is water-tight, and its matte colorful finish is smudge-proof.
It has high pigmentation which makes each color pigment bright and sharp which is great for accentuating and dramatic effects.
Uniquely lightweight, this water-infused texture eyeliner set glides on effortlessly and then dries down smoothly.
It is easy to clean as you can remove it with regular eye makeup remover. It wipes off fast and clean, and you never have to worry about pigmentation ‘leftover’, meaning there will be no damage to the skin or in the corners of the eyes.
Where To Buy
Amazon is the place to get these wonderfully bright colors. at $15.99 these are a good buy!
Stats
Only 104 reviews are available on this set, of which 47% gave it a 5 star.
As you would have it, some are great reviews and some are not, it is very individual. At 47% you can be pretty sure to have a good experience with this set.
Looking at reviews and ranking factors, this set of colored eyeliners is ranking is #47,916 in Amazon’s Best Seller Rank, still not bad for a relative newcomer and #390 in Eyeliners ranking.
Set #3 – 12 Colored Eyeliners – Matte Liquid Set, Waterproof Superstay Long Lasting Matte Eye Liner Pencil by Rechoo
Get Fantastic Colorful Makeup!
When you apply this colored eyeliner, you will realize that certain colored eyeliners look better on your specific skin tones than base black colors.
Suddenly, the rest of the makeup will look purposeful and fresh. And that’s exactly the kind of power of bright, bold, colorful eyeliners you need.
It makes you look playful and yet special. You can wear a single color, or add multiple colors, even use along with your base black eyeliner, that provides powerful eye makeup.
These vivid, bright matte eyeliner pens are available in 12 matte rainbow colors, they dry quickly, they are waterproof, and their highly pigmented formula makes them long-lasting with great staying power.
They do not go away with tears, eye drops, water, and are sweat-resistant, smudge-proof. These are long-wear formula, which means they really do stick without sliding or flaking until you wash it off.
Where to Buy
Recommended to purchase on Amazon, of course, the best price is available there.
Price: $17.98
Stats
Ranking at #234 in the Eye Liners section and at #30,409 in Beauty & Personal care, these eyeliners are really standing out for their quality and colorfulness.
Overall 208 customers have left very high reviews of which 50% were all 5 stars!
Set #4 – Glitter Liquid Eyeliner, Spdoo 10 Colors Waterproof Shimmer High Pigmented Silver Gold Metallic Colored Eyeliners
This brilliantly long-wearing liquid sparkle eyeliner glitter set will make your eyes pop out! (in a good way!)
The metallic glitter eyeliner provides you a super shining eye.
Each color contains holographic color effects for a truly unique look.
The colors included are Silver, Gold, Blue, Green, Purple, Dark Pink, Orange, Red, Yellow, and Fuscia.
You can apply it after you have drawn your black eyeliner base.
Where To Buy
Amazon provides the best price for this product and at $9.97 you simply cannot go wrong!
Stats
For a high ranking colored AND glitter eyeliners, this is THE best! Ranking $37 in the Eye Liners sections this little gem has a place of respect.
With 59% of its review stars being 5-star reviews, you can be sure you are buying a product that is worth your time!
Set #5 – BONNIE CHOICE 10 Colored Eyeliners (Glitter Liquid)
This Long-Lasting set of 10 Waterproof Sparkling Colored Eyeliners can be used both as a metallic eye shadow, or glitter eyeliner.
This is a pen that gives you shimmering eyes to make yourself stand out as unique as you truly are.
These eye shadows do not contain any animal-derived ingredients, and no animal testing has been made.
BONNIE CHOICE liquid eyeliners are waterproof, smudge-proof, and will last up 12 hours for its highly shimmering pigmented formula.
They are easy to apply & clean, as they go on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling; and they are also easy to remove with a simple makeup remover, fast and clean, you’ll never have to worry about pigmentation.
Where to Buy 
This set is available on Amazon at $19.99.
Stats
As we come along this great list of the colored eyeliners, the ranking goes a little down in the Amazon Best Sellers list at #161, 680 – it is still not bad when you consider the millions of eyeliner products out there!
It ranks #270 in the Nail Art Glitters (why it is in that category, only God knows…but that’s not for me to judge!).
Out of the 28 reviews, 55% of the people gave it a 5 Star review – which gives you a good indication that this product is well worth trying.
Set #6 – Fashionwu Waterproof Colored Eyeliners
This set of 12 different colored eyeliners displays a different charm for women, with its super pigmented eyeshadow it can offer awesome eye makeup definition for you.
The stylish colors meet most needs of cosmetic and make your eyes stand out in every style you can think of, they are THAT versatile!
This is a 3-IN-1 MAKEUP PEN which means that the pencils not only can be used as eyeliner pencils but also as eyeshadow pen & highlight pens.
These are waterproof and sweat-proof pens that can draw an exquisite line as eyeliners. The glitter effect is suitable for any daily makeup, party makeup, and professional makeup.
The eyeliner pens are colorful, soft in texture, and very convenient to use.
Where to Buy
This set is available on Amazon at $12.99
Stats
This little gem is ranking pretty nicely on Amazon’s Best seller’s list at #29,203 – which makes it quite reliable if you ask me.
In the Eye Liner category, it is ranking at #231 – again excellent ranking.
Out of the 117 reviews, this set has a 38% 5-star ranking, and when reviewing some of the good and bad it may all come down to your skin type.
Set #7 – Coosa Glitter Liquid Eyeliner 10PCS
This wonderful set of colored glitter eyeliners is a striking set with 10 different colors, included are Silver, Gold, Blue, Violet, Fuschia, and many more.
This colored eyeliners set is a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner.
The Coosa liquid eyeliner is not only waterproof, it is also smudge-proof, and will last up 12 hours for its highly shimmer pigmented formula.
It comes with a professional Ultra-Fine Brush which enables you a highly definitive line with its felt tip, it flows continuously and smoothly, dries down quickly, creating a delicate and attractive eyeliner.
It is easy to apply and clean as it goes on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling your delicate skin; and also it is easy to remove with makeup remover, it is fast and clean, you’ll never have to worry about pigmentation.
Where to Buy
The one place to find the best price is Amazon at $15.89 – this is a sure buy!
Stats
Ranking at #275 in the Eye Liner department on Amazon makes this one glitter set stand out. 62% of its 479 reviewers gave it a 5-star review – many saying how easy it is to apply and remove without leaving pigmentation and great value for your money.
You are sure to make a good and right decision with this little set.
Set #8 – FREEORR Matte Liquid Colored Eyeliners
This set of colored eyeliners offers you 12 different matte colors which are ideal for any occasion.
It comes with a unique package and is the perfect gift to your friends, bestie, families.
Again this set is also long-lasting and easy maintenance, its waterproof, matte effect, provides you with vivid bright eyes and will last all day.
It is uniquely lightweight and has a water-infused texture, as it glides on effortlessly, and then dries down smoothly.
It is easy to apply as it goes on smoothly without skipping, smudging, or pulling your delicate skin. It is easily removed with eyeliner with makeup remover. Fast and clean, you’ll never have to worry about pigmentation.
Where to Buy
The best deal is to be had at Amazon at $16.69.
Stats
Ranking at #311 in the Eye Liners department, this set is ranked in a good place considering its competition.
48% of its 53 reviewers saw fit to give it a 5 Star ranking, being satisfied that it DOES what it says!
Key Takeaways
When it comes to selecting the right colored eyeliner set for you, you not only need to look at the price, the quality is of course important.
I would personally advise having a good look at the product ranking, and reviews, as they play a large part in the possible satisfaction (or lack of it) when you make your purchase.
Here, at BOF we try to bring you the best quality at the best price with ranking in mind – so you can get the best ‘bang for your buck’!
Click Here For More Wonderful Skin Care Products On Amazon
Founder & CEO of Beauty Over Fifty
AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE:
“When you buy something from this website, I may receive an affiliate commission. These are my opinions and are not representative of the companies that create these products. My reviews are based on my personal own experience and research. I never recommend poor quality products or create false reviews to make sales. It is my intention to explain products so you can make an informed decision on which ones suit your needs best.”
I just stumbled upon your post about eye liner. While I do not need it, lol, my wife is always obsessing over her looks.
She is not taking the aging thing to well! I tell her she earned that look, but I think I only add fuel to her fire!
I will certainly pass your site along to her and hopefully you can tame her savage side lol!
Thanks,
Brendojn
Thanks for the fun and positive comment. I am sure you wife will find my site insightful and full of really good tips to keep her beautiful looks! I think of aging as a good wine…just need to give it the ultimate coditions =)
Cheers,
Orion
[…] 8 Best Colored Eyeliners Sets […]
[…] 8 Best Colored Eyeliners Sets […]